王伟事件的真相果真如此？

库布其

MacArthur 发表于 2014-8-29 02:56
你朋友的说法跟美军机长Shane Orsborn的回忆录不符。。。 美国人回忆说撞了之后两架米格都消失了，只他们 ...

翻了翻这个访谈，确实撞了以后就没有提到过第二架飞机的事情了。
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/fr ... erviews/osborn.html

库布其

小老虎爹 发表于 2014-8-29 14:31
打捞歼八2那张照片，军坛的普遍看法是：假的。
因为EP-3是撞到了歼八2垂尾，螺旋桨把垂尾整个打碎了，歼八2 ...

两个当事人的说法有冲突：

按王伟的长机，飞行员赵宇事后回忆，歼-8B战机与美国EP-3E相撞后，王伟的战机呈右滚转下俯状坠落，飞机失去控制。王伟曾对长机请示跳伞，长机同意后随即弹射，弹射后，长机还在弹射区3000米高度盘旋，发现空中飘有座椅稳定伞和救生伞各一具，确定弹射成功，在纪录王伟弹射位置后，长机返航。

美机机长：
Did you see what happened to the Chinese pilot?

Sure. As we were inverted going in a dive towards the ocean, I remember looking out and seeing half of his jet -- the front half, because [the prop] cut him in half -- with flames shooting out of the back of it screaming towards the earth. I remember going, "Wow he's in a bad way." I just remember thinking we were falling at the same rate he was, so I knew we had to be falling at 10,000 feet per minute easily. It was like looking at Vietnam War footage. That's what it reminded me of.

美机机长说，王的战机被螺旋桨切成了2段，前半段冒着火落下去了。


我自己的感觉，如果真的弹射，开伞，然后海面踪迹全无，有点不可思议。如果前半段机身落入海底遍寻不着，可以理解。